ISSN 2150-5128
University of Delaware Research Online Magazine

ONLINE MAGAZINE VOL 8 • NO 2

University of Delaware Research Online Magazine

ONLINE MAGAZINE

A Jewish Oral History

Historian Roger Horowitz sees many opportunities for collecting the oral histories of diverse populations, those who lived through historic events, those with specific expertise, those at all levels of society.

“Everybody has a story,” he said. “Oral histories bring students into a conversation with the past. By its nature, oral history engages the community.” Pre-pandemic photo by Evan Krape

7
It may have started in that Garden, when Adam was caught wearing a fig-leaf loincloth and eating fruit from a forbidden tree. Asked about this trespass, he said: “The woman whom you gave to be with me — Eve —s he gave me fruit from the tree and I ate.” Eve verified this, giving her own account and adding to what was perhaps the first oral history preserved by the Jewish Scriptures. Those Scriptures are packed with accounts of Jewish life, tradition, faith, genealogy, joy, oppression and redemption. Oral histories — accounts of life as lived by the speaker — can offer insight on any culture, community or episode. This past year at the University of Delaware, historian Roger Horowitz taught students how to collect such stories from senior members of the Jewish population in Wilmington, Delaware. The project enlightened those on both sides of the microphones and offered glimpses into the seldom-explored Jewish experience after World War II.

It's quite possible that every day you walk past, talk over or are simply oblivious to some of the most interesting stories on our planet. That person across the street, down the hall or next to you on the couch, for example — how much do you really know about them and their experiences?

If you learned the art of the interview and the craft of the oral history, you might discover you are in the company of many astonishing souls.

Long before there were text messages, property records, depositions or love letters, before there was a keyboard, printing press, quill pens or even crudely sharpened stones that could carve into the wall of a cave, people were learning about life from other people’s stories.

Thousands of years later, we still like learning things that way, says historian Roger Horowitz.

“The past is not abstract,” he said. “It’s about John, Sam, Irving, Phyllis. And that connects with the way we most want to learn about history — through their stories.”

Last fall, Horowitz taught students at the University of Delaware how to capture and curate such stories, collaborating with the Jewish Historical Society of Delaware on an oral history project that focused on senior members of the Jewish population in Wilmington, Delaware.

Oral History Class

ABOVE: Oral History Class with (back row, left to right) Gail Pietrzyk, archivist for the Jewish Historical Society of Delaware, historian Roger Horowitz, University of Delaware students Jordan Spencer, Fiona Sia, Jacob Budd, Benjamin Glazer and (front row, left to right) Dalia Handelman, Dale Weiss, Laura Mays and Megan Heston. Pre-pandemic photo by Evan Krape.

Horowitz is an excellent guide for such a task. He has the history chops, with a doctorate from the University of Wisconsin, expertise in the history of business, technology and industry, and extensive experience with oral histories. He has done such projects himself, including one focused on the United Packinghouse Workers of America in the 1980s and more recently with workers at the Chrysler plant in Newark, Delaware, which once operated on the grounds of what is now UD’s STAR Campus.

He is a member and leader in the Oral History Association, which has an extensive network of historians and offers comprehensive information on principles and best practices of these projects.

Historian Roger Horowitz


Roger Horowitz is director of Hagley Museum’s Center for the History of Business, Technology and Society and teaches history and Jewish Studies as an adjunct professor at UD. Pre-pandemic photo by Evan Krape.

“The past is not abstract. It’s about John, Sam, Irving, Phyllis. And that connects with the way we most want to learn about history — through their stories.”

— ROGER HOROWITZ
Gail Pietrzyk
Gail Pietrzyk, archivist for the Jewish Historical Society, worked with students to connect with senior members of Wilmington’s Jewish population. “Our members have been quite enthusiastic about working with the UD students.” Pre-pandemic photo by David Barczak.
“The structure and training and enthusiasm that Roger is able to provide is crucial,” said Gail Pietrzyk, archivist for the Jewish Historical Society. “For the students, asking someone for an interview may feel intrusive. But being interviewed by a student gives the interviewee an opportunity to feel their insight and experience and life is worth sharing.”

University researchers must observe careful protocols and safeguards when dealing with human subjects, ensuring informed consent and other protections, and that can be a painstaking process at times.

“But knowing that all the i’s are dotted and the t’s are crossed and that thought is given to preparation and planning gives us a great sense of security, that it has been handled carefully,” Pietrzyk said. “I’m delighted that these interviews are being created, just delighted.”

The interviewees ranged from about 70 years old to more than 100. They had much to share about Jewish life after World War II. Some wondered why their stories were of interest or value to anyone.

“There is a hole in Jewish history regarding those who were not part of the Holocaust,” said UD junior Dalia Handelman, a communication major from Bethesda, Maryland. “One person asked me, ‘Why are you talking to me?’ But afterward she said she felt so good. She had something important to say. Post-War Jews played a huge part in the establishment of the state of Israel.”

The experiences of these elders have not been the focus of much research, but they reveal context and nuanced perspectives that can inform our understanding of the past and its influence on the present. They described family and community life, Sabbath customs, experiences in business, education and encounters with anti-Semitism.

Many interviewees shared stories about the iconic tin Blue Box, known as the “pushke,” which has been used in Jewish households for more than a century. Families placed donations into that box for the Jewish National Fund, which first used the money to purchase land in Palestine and then to support the nation’s establishment.

“When they were growing up, Israel wasn’t even a nation yet,” Handelman said. “It was being established. It is 70 years old now and a thriving technology center. They knew a time when there was none of that. You can learn from anyone — and the advice they’d give is so important to listen to.”

She pointed to a powerful memory from Holocaust survivor Ann Jaffe, who said she was filled with hatred after the experience.

“Her father sat her down and asked, ‘We were victims of hatred, did you like it?’ Ann quickly responded, ‘I hated it, of course, I hated it.’ And her father said, ‘Then why would you do to others the thing that was so hateful to you?’”

Such wisdom can transform you.

“If a woman like her can let go of hatred, then we should all be able to do so as well,” Handelman said.

P
P
P
P
P

Handelman set the table for UD’s 2019 class by working as an intern with Horowitz in UD’s Summer Scholars program, which gives undergraduate students experience in research. During that internship, she interviewed 10 people for the project, including Faith and Lou Brown of Brandywine Hundred.

During her interview with the Browns, Dalia and Faith discovered they had a shared experience — volunteer duty with the Israeli army. Faith’s duty took place shortly after Israel’s birth as a nation in 1948 and included many subsequent trips and tasks such as assembling and cleaning Uzi machine guns. Dalia’s service came during her high-school years.

The significance of these kinds of conversations was made clear again earlier this year, when two of the people Dalia interviewed in the summer of 2019 passed away — Faith Brown’s husband, Lou, and Yetta Chaiken, a 1943 graduate of UD who provided significant support for UD’s Jewish Studies Program and was awarded the University’s Medal of Distinction in 1999.

“We are so grateful that the UD program helped us to preserve their stories and celebrate the remarkable lives recorded in all of the interviews,” Pietrzyk said.

Handelman met with students in Horowitz’s 2019 fall semester class as they learned the elements of doing oral history well. They learned how to manage logistics, the best places to conduct an interview, how to structure an interview. They planned their questions and learned how to record the interviews and write summaries of them.

Almost 20 people — with deep insight into business, education, health care, sports, faith and culture — sat for those interviews, most often recorded in their homes.

“What I valued most was the ability to have a conversation with people who have lived a long life and have made some major contributions to the world,” said Jordan Spencer, who graduated in May with a degree in history education and a minor in political science. “After interviewing them, I was able to see the power and impact of the legacy that they have created. In their story it became evident that wherever they went they positively impacted someone’s life. I can say that they have already given back to the world and have created a legacy that is everlasting.”

Spencer said he was surprised by the clarity with which many recalled events and dates. One couple he interviewed helped each other remember specifics, too.

Memories fade, of course, and sometimes stories get mixed up, exaggerated or misinterpreted. Some historians discount the value of oral histories for those reasons. Horowitz makes a strong case for them.

“Yes, memory is fallible,” he said. “And also, people often change stories to make themselves seem better or more important than they may have been so it’s regarded as a source that can be inaccurate. But all sources can be inaccurate. Many sources that are written sources are just written down oral sources, such as articles written by journalists, based on oral interviews.”

Supplementary research is always needed to verify, clarify and provide context.

ABOVE: Roger Horowitz, an adjunct faculty member in UD’s history department and an affiliated professor with the Hagley Program, geared his Fall 2019 HIST400: History Capstone Seminar class toward “Oral History and The Jewish Experience.” For this class, he partnered with the Jewish Historical Society of Delaware to have his students interview members of Delaware’s Jewish community about their life and experiences. Pre-pandemic video by Ally Quinn.

The Jewish Historical Society plans to post the UD interviews on its website and add these new materials to its considerable holdings housed at the Delaware Historical Society, where they are available to other researchers, Pietrzyk said. The coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic put a halt to interviews in 2020, but Handelman continued the work this past summer, transcribing the interviews and identifying portions that would be useful for the historical society’s website.

“Roger has been really supportive and helpful and has worked with us to nurture that link with Hagley and UD,” she said. “We have talked to Roger about training other people to do oral histories. We can’t thank them enough. It’s a blessing. We’ve got some wonderful collections to share. As a historian, I know the value of going to these documents…. You read these documents and you see the real life, as it was happening, not filtered or presented.”

Many of Horowitz’s students had no previous deep understanding of the Jewish experience. But the project was special in a personal way for Handelman, who said she grew up in a thriving Jewish community.

“I learned so much from each person,” she said, “and I have seen how me caring and putting in the time talking to these people affects them. I get messages from them like: ‘You should call me. I want to know what’s up with your life!’

“And being 19, communicating with people who are 90 to 100 years old is very special. I can’t stress that enough. I wrote down quotes that I never want to forget — and they don’t even realize it. I have left some interviews almost crying.”

History has enormous power when brought to the personal, relational level. And it always holds surprises. Horowitz experienced that during a series of interviews — 20 hours in all — he did with his stepfather, Al Johnson, to explore his stepfather’s military service in World War II, Korea and Vietnam.

“Tell me about your first memory,” Horowitz suggested, to get things going.

“It was the day my parents left me,” his stepfather replied. He then related a complex story of family history Horowitz had never heard before. A month later, Al Johnson died of asbestosis.

So don’t wait. Make that appointment. Write down some questions. Listen well. Take careful notes. Get to know someone — for their sake, for yours, for all of us.

Jack Lundy

Much history was shared during the oral history interviews, including stories about:

  • Keeping carp in the bathtub in order to make gefilte (stuffed) fish for Sabbath or Passover meals
  • TV test patterns that filled screens before 24-hour broadcasting was the standard
  • Party-line telephones
  • Having to cross the Delaware River by ferry because the bridges did not yet exist
  • Going to racially segregated schools, then going to community dances with Black students
  • Red-lined areas where Jewish families could not purchase homes
  • Rules and regrets about intermarriage between Jews and non-Jews
  • Traditions brought from Russia and Ukraine
  • Patriarchal customs
  • The desire to assimilate into American life and the loss of some traditions
  • How one interviewee established dental care for indigent students in the Christina School District
  • Drifting from the faith and returning to it after a death in the family
  • Encounters with anti-Semitism, overt and subtle
  • The pride of Jewish heritage
  • One fraternity, one sorority that Jewish students could join at UD
  • The challenges of keeping a kosher house
  • Attending Hebrew school five days each week
  • Restricted roles of women at the synagogue
  • Collecting money to support the creation of the Israeli nation
  • Being the only Jewish man on a U.S. military base in Morocco
  • Growing up as a Jew in Memphis, Tennessee
  • House calls by doctors that cost $2 per visit
  • Playing phonograph records with Hebrew and Yiddish folk songs on the Victrola
  • Purchasing a new home for $7,000, paying $20 a month for rent, 12 cents a gallon for gas
  • Spending 21 days seasick on a Turkish steamer to get to Israel in 1949
  • Israeli music festivals and dance groups

MORE STORIES

News Briefs

News Briefs

Check out our COVID-19 research, a virtual visit with the editor-in-chief of Science, and undergrads at work on the Frontiers of Discovery.

read more
A Robotics Revolution

A Robotics Revolution

Researchers at the University of Delaware are leveraging robotic systems to gain traction on tough problems. Learn how they are driving forward transformative solutions in agriculture, precision medicine, health care, cybersecurity, marine ecology and more.

read more
UD Robotics: Antarctic food webs

UD Robotics: Antarctic food webs

University of Delaware researchers Matthew Oliver and Katherine Hudson think that some biological hotspots in Antarctica may operate less like local farms and more like grocery stores. If they are correct, it could provide new information about how this ecosystem will be affected under climate change.

read more
UD Robotics: Social Robots

UD Robotics: Social Robots

Children have grown up with interactive technologies like Siri, Google and Alexa, but they don’t always know how to stay safe online. UD researchers are working on ways to help them.

read more